Agroseguro

Farming insurance

>
>

Agroseguro

Case Study Contents

About Farm

Farm Name

Promoter: Cristina Carrillo (COAG Jaén Insurance Responsible)
Farmer: Dolores Valderrama López
Initiative: Agroseguro.

Year of foundation

1978

Location

Cazalilla, Jaén

Farm area/size of the organisation:

3.5 ha

Number of workers:

Family members and 8 seasonal workers.

Farm main activity:

Olives

Climate and soil characteristics

Expansive clays and continental climate of the Guadalquivir valley, with hot summers and dry winters. 400 mm of rainfall, decreasing year by year, with episodes of storms and hail.

Measure Information

Description of the measure

Agricultural insurance is a risk coverage resource available in the Spanish agricultural sector. The insurance has a public component, with Agroseguro being the managing institution at the national level.

The insurance has several systems of coverage. The yield insurance we are analysing in this case seeks to guarantee up to 75 % of the historical yields associated with a farm. This farm has a risk premium linked to the region to which it belongs, and this risk defines the price to be paid per hectare by the farmer who takes out the insurance.

Objective of the measure

The purpose is to guarantee incomes when an adverse weather event reduces the yield of a farm.

For harvest reductions below the reference yields of that farm, the farmer may report damages, charging the difference between 75% of the reference yield and the yield finally obtained, with a reference price of 30 cnt/kg (in 2014).

Justification of the choice

The farmer decided to take out insurance in 2014. Their rainfed plantation had a strong yield that year, which together with a warm and dry winter made them anticipate a low harvest the following year.

They took out the insurance in winter and in spring a heatwave damaged the flowering of the province of Jaén, making it the year with the lowest provincial production in the last decade.

Where did You get information of the measure from?

Information on insurance can be consulted directly on the Agroseguro website.

Agrarian insurance is distributed through multiple institutions: insurance brokers, financial institutions, cooperatives, and agricultural associations.

These agents provide information, advice, and insurance processing.

Description of the situation before the measure implementation

This example describes a rainfed olive grove with wide variations in production (the “vecería”). This productive alternation is due to variations derived from climatic cycles, management under a non-irrigated system and the variability of the olive tree itself as a specie.

Stakeholders

Stakeholders involved

Agricultural organisations, insurance brokers, cooperatives, financial institutions.

Description of stakeholders’ role

COAG Jaén, like other agricultural insurance intermediaries, offers information, training, advice and processing of Agroseguro policies.

The offered services include the preparation of yield calculations, the preparation of budgets and the identification of the module that best suits the farm.

Implementation phase

Description of the survey done for the implementation

In the decision-making process, it is necessary to assess the characteristics of the farm in order to decide which type of insurance module to take out. Some of the criteria to consider are annual or biannual coverage, plot or farm level coverage, damage or yield coverage, etc.

Costs for the implementation

The current cost is around €50/ha. It is the result of applying a 75% subsidy from public funds, which is also included in the tax return.

This cost can be reduced in successive contracts through bonuses and discounts, the aim of which is to ensure the loyalty of farmers who enter the insurance system.

Utilization of subsidies

75% subsidy from public funds.

Implementation / building

Registration in the CIAS database of the Ministry of Agriculture is needed, so that a starting yield is assigned, which is the reference for all calculations.

The insurance is taken out by adjusting the contract parameters: duration, % coverage, plot or farm scale, etc.

In case of an expected low production, the farmer has to inform Agroseguro, which assesses the impact and applies the compensation.

Required maintenance operations

Benchmarks may vary over time. The recalculation of reference yields can be requested to adjust the values upwards. The reference prices, which are published in the BOE (Official State Journal) by Agroseguro, are adjusted. And the risk premiums associated with each farmer are updated based on their contracting and claims history.

Recommended knowledge / skills / training / courses / education desired before starting the measure implementation:

The system is complex due to the number of modules, coverages and the insurance operation.

It is essential to make knowledge accessible and to adapt the best options to each farm. Case studies, simulations and positive experiences are useful for this purpose.

Ideally, farmers should be able to define their own scenarios, based on a whole understanding of the system.

Impacts

With 0 yield, the insurance guarantees up to 75% with an excess of 10% and a reference price of 30cnt/€ (in 2014). In the case of Dolores, their reference yield for 350 trees was 56kg/tree. Considering 0kg of production, the result was:

350 trees x 56kg/tree (reference yield) x (75% coverage – 10% excess) x 0,3€/kg = €3.969 €.

Reduces uncertainty and sustains income, buffering poor harvest years. For agricultural regions the economic and social impact could be very important with a higher penetration of contracting.

It is a balanced system for the current climatic situation in Spain, but the evolution of climate change and its impacts in the medium and long term raises questions.

In a dynamic of recurrent droughts, an entry of many farmers into the system with massive claims would attack its sustainability.

Innovation

Innovation elements

Agrarian insurance is a success story of the Spanish agricultural system, an innovative method with a long tradition, in constant evolution, which seeks a balance in order to better adapt to the needs of farmers.

Key element for success

  • High plot yields.
  • Productive regions.
  • Farm homogeneity.
  • Continuity in contracting.
  • Professional farmers.
  • Select best moments to report damages.
  • Use your own experiences and do not rely on the opinions of third parties.
  • Configure insurance parameters to the reality of the farm.

Constraints

Physical constraints

  • The calculation of yields is not always accurate in terms of performance, planting frames, age of planting, etc.
  • Prices are perceived by farmers as expensive.
  • Contracting deadlines come before the end of the previous harvest, which in some cases makes it difficult to forecast climatic impacts.

Technological constraints

  • Systems are complex; their understanding and contracting conditions are not always understood by farmers, which discourages many of them.
  • The administrative and bureaucratic side is complex and mistakes in processing can lead to problems in compensation claims.

Acceptance constraints

  • The system discourages farms with low reference yields or small farms.
  • The bad experiences of some farmers discourage others from taking out insurance.
  • Despite being an essential tool, only 1% of farmers take out insurance.

Proposed solutions to above constraints

  • Agroseguro is making an effort to adjust the model to the needs of farmers, but there are sectors such as olive groves that need to achieve a better balance.
  • The adjustment of reference yields and a better knowledge on the part of farmers are fundamental factors for a better future implementation.

Lesson learned

Farmers’ experiences

Dolores and her family were satisfied, as they compensated for the loss of harvest while maintaining their income. Given this experience, they continue to take out insurance annually, enjoying better calculations and the bonuses due to continuity in the system.

Testimonies

“You need to be guided by your own experiences rather than by others”.

Measure sustainability

Economical sustainability

The economic sustainability of the agricultural sector in regions with drought cycles and production variability will be based on the contracting of risk management tools.
There are many challenges that the insurance system must face in order to increase its penetration in certain sectors or farms.

Transfer of the measure

Replicability conditions required

  • Professional farmers
  • High average yields
  • Economic dependence on agriculture
  • Decision making based on simulations and scenarios
  • Knowledge of measurement and evaluation protocols
  • Regions with high averages (conditions initial assessment)
  • Permanence in the system

Additional Required Conditions for spreading the measure

  • It is aimed at professional farmers with high production averages, whose income depends on agriculture and are compensated in the medium term.
  • It should be carried out based on simulation exercises and working with scenarios.
  • Measurement and evaluation based on protocols and historical data.
  • Farmers with high regional averages that initially condition the entry into the system.
  • The calculation of reference yields is fundamental. They are usually better adjusted for farmers with a background in the system than for new entrants.

The system is managed by public entities that depend on the Ministry of Agriculture. There is strong government support for this model of agricultural insurance. It would be necessary to set up these public agencies and generate the necessary budget to build the system. The aim is not to reward profit but to create a system in which some crops and regions compensate others, with a net result of the system that does not generate a deficit.

Conclusion remarks

Climate change makes necessary to integrate agricultural insurance as a managing tool to reduce risk on farms.
The complexity of the system and its constraints discourage many farmers from taking it out. A review of the model is needed to generate a more balanced system.
Increased dissemination and training should improve penetration in the sector.

Future plans

From Dolores’ point of view, taking out insurance has become an important tool, which continues to be taken out.
From Agroseguro’s point of view, changes to its system are expected soon, and it is making a great effort to adapt to the needs of the farmers.

Open problems

The system of contracting and benchmark crop assessment discourages many farmers. For some, it is perceived as expensive insurance.
It generates more interest among professional farmers with high average yields in productive regions.
Greater dissemination and training are needed.

Advice/recommendations

“Obtaining information and advice from the system is needed to integrate it as a management tool”.

“You need to be guided by your own experiences rather than by others”.

ES03_04

AGRIWATER project has been funded with the support from the European Commission, with the reference number 2020-1-CZ01-KA204-078212. The content of this website reflects the views only of the author, and the Commission cannot be held responsible for any use which may be made of the information contained therein.

Privacy Policy

At AGRIWATER we take the protection of your personal data very seriously. Our purpose is to protect the privacy of the data you provide us and to comply with the current regulations on the protection of personal data.

In compliance with the Act 3/2018 of 5 December on the Protection of Personal Data and Guarantee of Digital Rights transposing Regulation (EU) 2016/679, we inform you of the following information about our privacy and data protection policy:

Who the controller of the processing of your data?

The organization responsible of your data is Asociace soukromeho zemedelstvi Ceske republiky, ID E10133738. This is a non-governmental organization located in Prague, Czech Republic.

Address
Samcova 1177/1
11000
Praha 1

Telephone
+420266710413
+420266710414

Email contact
marketa.sandova@asz.cz

What is the purpose of the treatment?
  • To respond to requests, complaints and incidents transferred through our contact channels incorporated in the website.
  • To understand the behaviour of the navigator within the web in order to detect possible computer attacks on our web.
  • Comply with legal obligations that are directly applicable to us and regulate our activity.
  • To protect and exercise our rights or to respond to complaints of any kind.
  • Submission of newsletters regarding the goods or services that make up the activity of the responsible person or news related to his activity.

 

What is the legal base of the treatment?

The legal basis for the treatment of your data is the consent of the data subject under article 6.1 a) of the Regulation, as well as the legitimate interest of the data controller under article 6.1 f) of the Regulation.

The data we request from you are adequate, relevant and strictly necessary and in no case are you obliged to provide them to us, but their non-communication may affect the purpose of the service or the impossibility of providing it.

For how long do we keep your data?

Your data will be kept for the time required for the proper provision of the service offered, as well as to meet the responsibilities that may arise from it and any other legal requirement.

Which recipients will receive your data?

In the course of processing your data, Asociace soukromeho zemedelstvi Ceske republiky may share your data with:

On Projects Advising SL, as web management and maintenance service providers.

What are my rights?
  • Right of access: the right to obtain confirmation of whether personal data is being processed, as well as the right of access to such data.
  • Right to rectification of personal data.
  • Right to erasure
  • Right to limitation of processing
  • Right to data portability
  • Right to object: the right to object to data being processed.

The controller retains the right to restrict the rights set forth in Article 23 of the EU Regulation, if such restriction is provided to safeguard, in particular fundamental rights and freedoms and is a necessary and proportionate measure.

Where can I make a complaint?

If any interested party considers that their data are not being treated correctly, they can send their complaints to the following e-mail address; kristyna.strnadova@asz.cz, Asociace soukromeho zemedelstvi Ceske republiky.

The data subject declares to have acquired all this information.

Cookies Policy

What are cookies?

A cookie is a file that is downloaded and executed on your computer, phone, or mobile device when you access certain web pages. Cookies allow a website, among other things, to store and retrieve information about user’s browsing habits and recognize the user depending on the information they contain and the way they use their computer.

Cookies do not harm your computer and are necessary to facilitate navigation.

What are cookies used for on our website?

Cookies are necessary for our website to work properly. The purpose of our cookies is to improve the user’s browsing experience. They can be used to remember your preferences (language, country, etc.) during navigation and on future visits.

The information collected in the Cookies also allows us to improve the website and adapt it to the individual interests of users, speed up searches, etc.

What types of cookies does our website use?

Analysis Cookies: These, if they are used properly by us or by third parties, allow us to quantify the number of users and thus perform the measurement and statistical analysis regarding the users’ usage of our service.

Advertising Cookies: These, if they are used properly by us or by third parties, allow us to manage as effectively as possible the supply of advertising space on the website, adapting the content of the advertisement to the content of the service requested or to the use you make of our website.

What we will NOT use cookies for

Our cookies do not store information about your personal identification, address, password, credit or debit card details, etc.

Who uses the information contained in these cookies?

The information stored in the website’s cookies is used exclusively by us, apart from those identified below as “third party cookies”, which are used and managed by external entities to provide us with services to improve our own services and the user’s experience when browsing our website.

Third party cookies are mainly used to obtain statistics and to guarantee the payment operations are carried out.

Can I prevent cookies from being used?

Yes, firstly, you must disable cookies in your browser and, secondly, delete the cookies stored in your browser associated with this website.

You can restrict, block, or delete cookies from this website at any time by modifying your browser settings. This setting is different for each browser. For more details on the configuration of cookies in your browser, please consult your browser’s “Help” menu.

It is possible that some of the website’s features may no longer work if you disable cookies.

List of cookies that our website uses
Technical and customization cookies

These Cookies are used to identify the user during the session, prevent the user from having to repeat authentication processes on the website, speed up some website processes, remember selections made during the session or on subsequent accesses, remember pages already visited, etc.

COOKIES

PURPOSE

DURATION

MANAGEMENT

User identification

They are used to identify and authenticate the user. They also contain technical data from the user session, such as connection timeout, session identifier, etc.

Session

AGRIWATER

Session identification

They identify the user’s http session. They are common in all web applications to identify requests from a user’s session.

Session

AGRIWATER

Navigation status

They help identify the user’s browsing status (login, first page, first access, scroll status, voting status, etc.).

Session

AGRIWATER

Navigation analysis cookies

These Cookies obtain generic information about users’ accesses to the website (not the content of the same) to subsequently provide us with information about these accesses for statistical purposes.

COOKIES

PURPOSE

DURATION

MANAGEMENT

Google Analytics (__utma, __utmb, __utmc, __utmd, __utmv, __utmz, _ga…)

They allow website statistic’s tracking through the Google Analytics tool, which is a service provided by Google to obtain information about user access to websites. Some of the data stored is: number of times a user visits the website, dates of the user’s first and last visit, duration of visits, from which page the user accessed the website, which search engine was used or which link was clicked, from which part of the world the user accessed the website, etc. The information generated by the cookie about your use of the website will be directly transmitted and stored by Google Inc (a company located in United States). The configuration of these cookies is predetermined by the service offered by Google, so we suggest you consult the Google Analytics privacy page, for more information on the cookies it uses and how to disable them (keep in mind that we are not responsible for the content and accuracy of third-party websites).

Persistent

Third Parties